University of the West Indies professor Professor Sonjah Stanley Niaah has challenged Prime Minister Dr Andrew Holness’ response to Beenie Man‘s criticism of the Government’s Hurricane Melissa relief efforts, arguing that the dancehall veteran deserved information rather than a public reprimand. Speaking with journalist Anthony Miller on TVJ’s Entertainment Report on Friday, November 13, the cultural studies scholar, popularly known as the ‘Culture Doctor’, described the Prime Minister’s response as “a little high handed, a little over the top”, adding that it was inappropriate to tell Beenie Man he should know better.
The controversy follows Beenie Man’s appearance on UK television, where he questioned the distribution of Hurricane Melissa relief funds, claiming that money received was not reaching the intended beneficiaries. Holness subsequently rejected the entertainer’s assertions, describing them as a lie told by someone who benefits from Brand Jamaica. However, Stanley Niaah argued that the deejay was not speaking out of hostility towards Jamaica. “He wasn’t making that statement because he was trying to be, let’s say, an anti-Jamaican,” she said, insisting that entertainers should be able to contribute to important national discussions without their patriotism being questioned.
Stanley Niaah also defended the wider contribution of Jamaican entertainers and athletes to the country’s international reputation, describing Brand Jamaica as “a collective ownership”. She argued that musicians and sporting personalities have helped establish the nation’s global identity and should be recognised as stakeholders in its development. “They are the people who hold Brand Jamaica high every time,” she said, stressing that the country’s cultural ambassadors should not be expected to remain silent when major national issues arise.
Beyond the exchange between Beenie Man and the Prime Minister, the professor called for greater transparency surrounding Hurricane Melissa relief funding. Her concerns come amid scrutiny of the Office of Disaster Preparedness and Emergency Management (ODPEM), after an Auditor General’s report revealed that only 1.8 per cent of J$1.44 billion in cash donations received for Hurricane Melissa had been spent as at February 23, 2026. The Government has since outlined a much broader national recovery expenditure, with Holness reporting approximately J$84 billion spent on the hurricane response as at October 27, 2026. Stanley Niaah maintained that Jamaicans deserve clear information about the funds received, their allocation and the assistance reaching affected communities.
She also warned against allowing the controversy to fade without meaningful action, expressing hope that the Government would not treat the matter as another “nine day wonder”. With Hurricane Melissa’s impact continuing to shape national recovery discussions, Stanley Niaah’s intervention highlights a broader question about the relationship between Jamaica’s cultural ambassadors, political leadership and public accountability. For the Culture Doctor, those who help carry Brand Jamaica to the world must also have a voice when the country’s future is being discussed.
View this post on Instagram




